NIU
New member
- Joined
- Jan 4, 2026
- Messages
- 4
So, which factory actually makes good replica watches? What really torments newcomers isn't so much where to buy, but which factory to trust. Honestly, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. Each replica factory has its own area of expertise. While there isn't an official factory ranking, a three-tier ranking system has emerged over time from players' experiences. Think of this less as a "best of" list and more as a map to avoid pitfalls. Tier 1 is for "buy with your eyes closed," Tier 2 is for "choose based on your needs," and Tier 3 is for "take a gamble when the budget is tight." After reading this, you'll understand why there can be a price difference of several hundred dollars between, say, a CLEAN factory and a BP factory Rolex Submariner "Hulk," and whether that extra cost is worth it.
Tier 1: CLEAN Factory, VS Factory, APS Factory, ZF Factory, BV Factory, 3K Factory
This reputation wasn't handed to them; it was built brick by brick through countless teardown reviews and positive user feedback. CLEAN Factory's rise is legendary. Back when NOOB Factory dominated the Rolex scene, its eventual decline left a void. CLEAN Factory stepped in strong with the Daytona, Submariner, Yacht-Master, and GMT-Master II. With meticulous finishing and integrated movements, they had the right product at the right time, successfully replacing NOOB as the go-to for 1:1 Rolex replicas. Even today, CLEAN remains the top choice for Rolex, especially their Daytona series—simply unbeatable. VS Factory made its name with the Omega Seamaster 8500 integrated movement. At a time when fake decorated plate movements were common, they got the balance wheel position spot-on, ending the era of obvious plate cover-ups. Watch enthusiasts often say you never have to worry about a VS factory watch looking fake through the case back—perfect for social media pics. APS Factory is the dark horse. Their Audemars Piguet Royal Oak 15400 gained a reputation rivaling the veteran JF Factory within months of release, thanks to their 3120 integrated movement's correct "tick" position, quiet rotor bearings, and dense bracelet brushing. Later updates with 4302 and 4401 integrated movements swept up the chronograph models too, essentially tying the AP brand to APS Factory in the Chinese replica market. ZF Factory is like an old-school craftsman. They can polish the dial texture, date window step, and even the curve of the IWC Portugieser buckle rivets to perfection—scrutiny under a magnifying glass reveals no flaws. If someone mentions a "detail-obsessed" factory, they're definitely talking about ZF. BV Factory focuses on Cartier and Bulgari. Their Cartier Santos, in particular, has incredibly high visual accuracy, with case thickness replicated down to the millimeter. 3K Factory's masterpiece is Patek Philippe. Their 5711 series is still highly sought after, with a thickness pressed down to the genuine 8.3mm—thinner than some ETA-modified movements with plates. They are the undisputed king of Patek Philippe replicas.
Tier 2: AR Factory, MKS Factory, APW Factory, PPF Factory, AF Factory, YF Factory
AR Factory originally split from JF Factory to compete with NOOB in Rolex. After NOOB's decline, they stuck with Rolex but strategically avoided the super-hot classic models, focusing instead on Datejust, Yacht-Master, and other non-hype pieces. They fixed the ceramic bezel numeral fading issue in their 2023 versions. However, their hand polishing still isn't as good as CLEAN's, but their price is about $100 cheaper. Great for someone who wants a Rolex Datejust without spending big. MKS Factory specializes in the tough niche of simple three-hand dress watches: IWC Portofino, Omega De Ville, Jaeger-LeCoultre Master. They get the case under 9mm thin, but the trade-off is a louder rotor noise. Luckily, dress watches are often covered by sleeves, hiding the sound perfectly. APW Factory caused a stir in 2025 with their Patek Philippe 5168 blue and green dials, perfectly addressing the color issues found in 3K's versions, momentarily threatening 3K's throne. However, being so new, their movement stability hasn't stood the test of time yet. My advice? Let it simmer for another six months before considering buying. PPF Factory goes head-to-head with 3K, specializing in Patek Philippe and Vacheron Constantin. They nail the dial carbon pattern, font embossing, and movement noise reduction to a point where photos can't tell the difference, but they always fall slightly short on thickness compared to 3K, making them the perennial "second best" for Patek replicas. YF Factory has built a moat around women's watches: Chopard Happy Diamonds, Cartier Tank, Omega Constellation. They replace diamonds with high-quality cubic zirconia that sparkles just like the real thing, at a fraction of the price. The perfect choice for a replica watch as a gift for your girlfriend. AF Factory mainly does Longines and Cartier. They're known for value-for-money, balancing low price and decent quality. Compared to other factories that are expensive yet poorly made, AF is a practical choice.
Tier 3: BP Factory, TW Factory, OM Factory, GF Factory, etc
This tier is the battlefield of value and risk. One wrong move, and you might get a bad product. BP Factory was famous early on, making a name with Rolex Submariners. As Tier 1 evolved rapidly, BP could only compete by lowering prices. They now focus on entry-level three-hand models like Longines Master Collection or IWC Pilot. Their ETA 2824 movements with decorated plates have fake fish-scale patterns that look convincing, but the hand pinion is always thicker than the genuine. The upside? Their price is only one-third of Tier 1. Good for someone who just wants the style and isn't picky about details. TW Factory's quality control is a rollercoaster. What you get is pure luck. In the same batch of IWC watches, some function perfectly with good finishing, others won't even run. Their complicated function models are especially to be avoided—high chance they won't work properly. Their simple models are actually decent and affordable, but they really need to fix their QC issues. OM Factory is for the "appearance-first" crowd. Their Audemars Piguet Offshore, Omega Constellation, etc., look very close to 1:1, but the movement noise is loud, and they use common market movements, so an open case back is a dead giveaway. GF Factory specializes in Breitling replicas. They have the longest history but never became a top player. Exterior accuracy is okay, but the movements are still a bit lacking.
So, stop asking which factory is the absolute best. There's no all-around champion in the replica world, only specialists. Just remember this: If your budget allows and you want to avoid trouble, prioritize Tier 1. If your budget is tight and you're willing to gamble, consider Tier 3. For that same Rolex Submariner "Hulk," the few hundred dollars more for CLEAN over BP is essentially buying peace of mind and a more respectable finish. Factory rankings will change, but the logic of avoiding pitfalls remains the same. Save this replica factory ranking guide. Check it next time you want to buy, and you won't get ripped off. Hope you get it right on your first try and wear it with confidence.
Tier 1: CLEAN Factory, VS Factory, APS Factory, ZF Factory, BV Factory, 3K Factory
This reputation wasn't handed to them; it was built brick by brick through countless teardown reviews and positive user feedback. CLEAN Factory's rise is legendary. Back when NOOB Factory dominated the Rolex scene, its eventual decline left a void. CLEAN Factory stepped in strong with the Daytona, Submariner, Yacht-Master, and GMT-Master II. With meticulous finishing and integrated movements, they had the right product at the right time, successfully replacing NOOB as the go-to for 1:1 Rolex replicas. Even today, CLEAN remains the top choice for Rolex, especially their Daytona series—simply unbeatable. VS Factory made its name with the Omega Seamaster 8500 integrated movement. At a time when fake decorated plate movements were common, they got the balance wheel position spot-on, ending the era of obvious plate cover-ups. Watch enthusiasts often say you never have to worry about a VS factory watch looking fake through the case back—perfect for social media pics. APS Factory is the dark horse. Their Audemars Piguet Royal Oak 15400 gained a reputation rivaling the veteran JF Factory within months of release, thanks to their 3120 integrated movement's correct "tick" position, quiet rotor bearings, and dense bracelet brushing. Later updates with 4302 and 4401 integrated movements swept up the chronograph models too, essentially tying the AP brand to APS Factory in the Chinese replica market. ZF Factory is like an old-school craftsman. They can polish the dial texture, date window step, and even the curve of the IWC Portugieser buckle rivets to perfection—scrutiny under a magnifying glass reveals no flaws. If someone mentions a "detail-obsessed" factory, they're definitely talking about ZF. BV Factory focuses on Cartier and Bulgari. Their Cartier Santos, in particular, has incredibly high visual accuracy, with case thickness replicated down to the millimeter. 3K Factory's masterpiece is Patek Philippe. Their 5711 series is still highly sought after, with a thickness pressed down to the genuine 8.3mm—thinner than some ETA-modified movements with plates. They are the undisputed king of Patek Philippe replicas.
Tier 2: AR Factory, MKS Factory, APW Factory, PPF Factory, AF Factory, YF Factory
AR Factory originally split from JF Factory to compete with NOOB in Rolex. After NOOB's decline, they stuck with Rolex but strategically avoided the super-hot classic models, focusing instead on Datejust, Yacht-Master, and other non-hype pieces. They fixed the ceramic bezel numeral fading issue in their 2023 versions. However, their hand polishing still isn't as good as CLEAN's, but their price is about $100 cheaper. Great for someone who wants a Rolex Datejust without spending big. MKS Factory specializes in the tough niche of simple three-hand dress watches: IWC Portofino, Omega De Ville, Jaeger-LeCoultre Master. They get the case under 9mm thin, but the trade-off is a louder rotor noise. Luckily, dress watches are often covered by sleeves, hiding the sound perfectly. APW Factory caused a stir in 2025 with their Patek Philippe 5168 blue and green dials, perfectly addressing the color issues found in 3K's versions, momentarily threatening 3K's throne. However, being so new, their movement stability hasn't stood the test of time yet. My advice? Let it simmer for another six months before considering buying. PPF Factory goes head-to-head with 3K, specializing in Patek Philippe and Vacheron Constantin. They nail the dial carbon pattern, font embossing, and movement noise reduction to a point where photos can't tell the difference, but they always fall slightly short on thickness compared to 3K, making them the perennial "second best" for Patek replicas. YF Factory has built a moat around women's watches: Chopard Happy Diamonds, Cartier Tank, Omega Constellation. They replace diamonds with high-quality cubic zirconia that sparkles just like the real thing, at a fraction of the price. The perfect choice for a replica watch as a gift for your girlfriend. AF Factory mainly does Longines and Cartier. They're known for value-for-money, balancing low price and decent quality. Compared to other factories that are expensive yet poorly made, AF is a practical choice.
Tier 3: BP Factory, TW Factory, OM Factory, GF Factory, etc
This tier is the battlefield of value and risk. One wrong move, and you might get a bad product. BP Factory was famous early on, making a name with Rolex Submariners. As Tier 1 evolved rapidly, BP could only compete by lowering prices. They now focus on entry-level three-hand models like Longines Master Collection or IWC Pilot. Their ETA 2824 movements with decorated plates have fake fish-scale patterns that look convincing, but the hand pinion is always thicker than the genuine. The upside? Their price is only one-third of Tier 1. Good for someone who just wants the style and isn't picky about details. TW Factory's quality control is a rollercoaster. What you get is pure luck. In the same batch of IWC watches, some function perfectly with good finishing, others won't even run. Their complicated function models are especially to be avoided—high chance they won't work properly. Their simple models are actually decent and affordable, but they really need to fix their QC issues. OM Factory is for the "appearance-first" crowd. Their Audemars Piguet Offshore, Omega Constellation, etc., look very close to 1:1, but the movement noise is loud, and they use common market movements, so an open case back is a dead giveaway. GF Factory specializes in Breitling replicas. They have the longest history but never became a top player. Exterior accuracy is okay, but the movements are still a bit lacking.
So, stop asking which factory is the absolute best. There's no all-around champion in the replica world, only specialists. Just remember this: If your budget allows and you want to avoid trouble, prioritize Tier 1. If your budget is tight and you're willing to gamble, consider Tier 3. For that same Rolex Submariner "Hulk," the few hundred dollars more for CLEAN over BP is essentially buying peace of mind and a more respectable finish. Factory rankings will change, but the logic of avoiding pitfalls remains the same. Save this replica factory ranking guide. Check it next time you want to buy, and you won't get ripped off. Hope you get it right on your first try and wear it with confidence.
Last edited: