The Breitling Navitimer 1 (Ref. A17326211C1P3) stands as one of the most recognizable pilot's watches, with its signature slide rule bezel and clean aesthetic. V7 Factory has established itself as a leading producer of high-end replicas, and their take on this model deserves careful examination. This review provides an objective comparison between the replica and genuine timepiece, highlighting both strengths and weaknesses.
Case & Build Quality
The genuine Navitimer features a 41mm stainless steel case with refined polishing and precise bezel action. V7's replica matches these dimensions exactly, including the 10.3mm thickness, making it virtually identical in profile. Both watches use 316L steel, though the genuine model exhibits slightly superior finishing, particularly in the transitions between brushed and polished surfaces.
Where the replica shows its limitations is in the bezel operation. While functional, the rotation lacks the buttery smoothness of the genuine article. Interestingly, V7 claims 50m water resistance versus Breitling's 30m, though this remains unverified in practical testing.
Dial & Legibility
This is where the V7 replica truly shines. The blue sunburst dial, applied hour markers, and date window alignment are nearly indistinguishable from the genuine watch. The slide rule markings are crisp and fully functional, a testament to V7's attention to detail.
Lume application is good but not perfect. While initial brightness matches the genuine watch, the replica's lume fades noticeably faster. The hands maintain excellent proportions and finishing, though under high magnification, the edges appear slightly less refined than Breitling's exacting standards.
Movement Performance
The genuine Navitimer uses Breitling's Caliber 17 (based on ETA 2824-2), which is COSC-certified for precision. V7 offers two movement options: a Swiss SW200 clone and a Chinese Seagull 2824. The SW200 performs admirably, typically running within +5-10 seconds per day compared to the genuine +4s, while the Seagull version may show slightly more variance.
Power reserve is comparable at about 40 hours for both. The main noticeable difference is in rotor noise - the genuine movement operates more quietly, while the replica's rotor can be heard when moving the wrist abruptly.
Strap & Wearability
Breitling's genuine alligator strap sets a high bar with its supple feel and perfect stitching. V7's "super version" strap makes a valiant effort, using quality leather with good stitching, but feels stiffer initially and lacks the same luxurious edge finishing.
On the wrist, the replica wears nearly identically to the genuine piece. The weight distribution is correct, and the overall presence matches the original. Only upon close inspection by a trained eye do the minor differences in finishing become apparent.
Key Differences Summary
Where the Replica Excels:
- Perfect dimensional accuracy
- Remarkable dial reproduction
- Functional slide rule bezel
- Affordable alternative to the genuine article
Where It Falls Short:
- Bezel action not as refined
- Strap quality doesn't match Breitling's
- Lume performance inferior
- Movement finishing not as precise
Final Assessment
The V7 Factory's Navitimer 1 replica represents an impressive achievement in horological reproduction. It captures about 90-95% of the genuine watch's essence at a fraction of the price. For enthusiasts who admire the Navitimer's design but balk at its retail price, this replica offers a compelling alternative.
That said, it's not a perfect copy. The subtle differences in finishing, movement refinement, and strap quality remind us that even the best replicas must make compromises. Whether these matter depends entirely on the wearer's expectations and standards.
Discussion Questions:
1. How important is perfect bezel action in a replica watch - dealbreaker or negligible detail?
2. For those who've handled both: Does the replica maintain its appeal over time, or do the differences become more noticeable with extended wear?
We welcome your experiences and opinions in the comments below.
Case & Build Quality
The genuine Navitimer features a 41mm stainless steel case with refined polishing and precise bezel action. V7's replica matches these dimensions exactly, including the 10.3mm thickness, making it virtually identical in profile. Both watches use 316L steel, though the genuine model exhibits slightly superior finishing, particularly in the transitions between brushed and polished surfaces.
Where the replica shows its limitations is in the bezel operation. While functional, the rotation lacks the buttery smoothness of the genuine article. Interestingly, V7 claims 50m water resistance versus Breitling's 30m, though this remains unverified in practical testing.
Dial & Legibility
This is where the V7 replica truly shines. The blue sunburst dial, applied hour markers, and date window alignment are nearly indistinguishable from the genuine watch. The slide rule markings are crisp and fully functional, a testament to V7's attention to detail.
Lume application is good but not perfect. While initial brightness matches the genuine watch, the replica's lume fades noticeably faster. The hands maintain excellent proportions and finishing, though under high magnification, the edges appear slightly less refined than Breitling's exacting standards.
Movement Performance
The genuine Navitimer uses Breitling's Caliber 17 (based on ETA 2824-2), which is COSC-certified for precision. V7 offers two movement options: a Swiss SW200 clone and a Chinese Seagull 2824. The SW200 performs admirably, typically running within +5-10 seconds per day compared to the genuine +4s, while the Seagull version may show slightly more variance.
Power reserve is comparable at about 40 hours for both. The main noticeable difference is in rotor noise - the genuine movement operates more quietly, while the replica's rotor can be heard when moving the wrist abruptly.
Strap & Wearability
Breitling's genuine alligator strap sets a high bar with its supple feel and perfect stitching. V7's "super version" strap makes a valiant effort, using quality leather with good stitching, but feels stiffer initially and lacks the same luxurious edge finishing.
On the wrist, the replica wears nearly identically to the genuine piece. The weight distribution is correct, and the overall presence matches the original. Only upon close inspection by a trained eye do the minor differences in finishing become apparent.
Key Differences Summary
Where the Replica Excels:
- Perfect dimensional accuracy
- Remarkable dial reproduction
- Functional slide rule bezel
- Affordable alternative to the genuine article
Where It Falls Short:
- Bezel action not as refined
- Strap quality doesn't match Breitling's
- Lume performance inferior
- Movement finishing not as precise
Final Assessment
The V7 Factory's Navitimer 1 replica represents an impressive achievement in horological reproduction. It captures about 90-95% of the genuine watch's essence at a fraction of the price. For enthusiasts who admire the Navitimer's design but balk at its retail price, this replica offers a compelling alternative.
That said, it's not a perfect copy. The subtle differences in finishing, movement refinement, and strap quality remind us that even the best replicas must make compromises. Whether these matter depends entirely on the wearer's expectations and standards.
Discussion Questions:
1. How important is perfect bezel action in a replica watch - dealbreaker or negligible detail?
2. For those who've handled both: Does the replica maintain its appeal over time, or do the differences become more noticeable with extended wear?
We welcome your experiences and opinions in the comments below.